Only three people know the recipe for Jordan’s Restaurant’s carrot cake. Gemma, Jordan’s own wife and business partner, isn’t one of them.
“I keep it a secret from everybody, basically,” Jordan said with a laugh — a fitting bit of mystery for a restaurant that’s spent a decade quietly building its reputation one dish, one wedding, and one food trailer at a time before ever opening a storefront.
The story starts in 2015, when Jordan and Gemma launched a catering business shortly after Jordan finished culinary school. Weddings and other events kept them busy on the side, and their two children were pulled into the family operation early — helping out however a young kid can at a catering gig. Both are grown now, and both still work alongside their parents today. From catering, the business grew into a food trailer, giving Jordan and Gemma their first real taste of running something with a fixed spot and a regular following.
Jordan grew up in the area, which made it feel almost inevitable when an old tea house locally known as The Lantern came up for sale. The timing wasn’t ideal — COVID hit right as they were working through the purchase — but Jordan and Gemma made their offer anyway, and Jordan’s opened its doors in Norwich in 2022. “We’ve been in Norwich here for four years,” Jordan said, “and what’s kept us going is the people.”
That focus shows up on the plate. Jordan’s built its menu around fresh, homemade comfort food — fried chicken, meatloaf, sandwiches, fresh-cut fries, daily specials, and burgers made with 100 percent Ontario beef and no fillers. And then there’s dessert, where the restaurant has quietly built its strongest following. The carrot cake, guarded so tightly that even Gemma doesn’t have the recipe, has become something of a local legend in its own right — one of those items regulars specifically drive in for.
Even so, when asked what he’s proudest of, Jordan doesn’t lead with the food. “Honestly, we’re probably most proud of the community here,” he said. Customers have become close enough that some, he jokes, seem to know more about what’s happening at the restaurant on a chaotic night than Jordan and Gemma do themselves.
Running a restaurant has taught Jordan that no amount of planning can fully prepare you for a Friday night. “You have to be adaptable,” he said. “Things don’t always go accordingly to plan, and are definitely unpredictable.” On the toughest nights, he and Gemma have learned there’s really only one option: catch each other’s eye, laugh it off, and keep moving forward. Just as important as what comes out of the kitchen, Jordan says, is remembering a regular’s name, getting someone’s favourite meal just right, or sharing a laugh with a customer having a rough day.
That grounded approach carries directly into his advice for anyone thinking of starting their own business. “Be proud of your work,” he said, before rattling off a more candid list: be ready for long hours, keep learning constantly, and expect to question your life choices from time to time. On a more practical note, he stresses listening closely to customers and staying true to whatever makes your business genuinely unique — while never being afraid to try something new, even when it doesn’t land the way you hoped.
New ideas, it turns out, come to Jordan constantly. He keeps a running notebook of them — menu concepts, weekly specials, dessert promotions, and the occasional wilder idea, like a trivia night at the restaurant — jotting things down the moment they occur to him, whether or not they end up making sense later. “Sometimes it makes sense, sometimes it doesn’t,” he said, “but at least I don’t lose any of the ideas.” Ask him what’s specifically next for Jordan’s, and his honest answer is that even he doesn’t fully know yet. Maybe it’s another food trailer down the road, maybe it’s something else entirely — the notebook, he figures, will tell him when the time is right.
What keeps Jordan and Gemma rooted in Norwich is simple: the people. “Rural Oxford has an incredible sense of community here in Norwich,” Jordan said. Locals genuinely support one another’s businesses and root for their neighbours’ success, a dynamic he and Gemma feel every time a familiar face walks through the door or they run into a customer while out for a walk uptown. “Customers can quickly become friends,” he said, “and sometimes become people you see more than your own family.”
Jordan’s is open Wednesday through Saturday — 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Wednesday and Thursday, 11 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. Friday, and 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Saturday — with the restaurant closed Sunday through Tuesday. Behind the counter and in the kitchen, the team includes about eight employees, three of them full-time, with Gemma stepping in whenever her schedule allows around her day job. Between the two of them, their kids, and their staff, Jordan describes the restaurant as very much a family effort, in more ways than one.
More than anything, Jordan wants the people who’ve supported Jordan’s along the way to know how much it’s meant. “We really just want to say thank you to every person who has walked through our doors, ordered a burger, fried chicken, or some crazy special we thought of, or just came to grab a coffee, shared one of our posts, or told a friend about us,” he said. “That’s helped make Jordan’s and Gemma’s what it is today.”
From a wedding catering side hustle to a food trailer to a converted tea house on Stover Street, Jordan’s has grown the same way its carrot cake recipe has stayed secret — quietly, carefully, and entirely on its own terms.
Jordan’s Restaurant
Jordan & Gemma
37 Stover St S, Norwich, ON
Norwich Township
Established 2015
jordansrestaurantandcatering.com
Instagram
Facebook